Short answer: There’s no official number, but here’s the honest pattern I’ve seen play out again and again: the first cancellation gets forgiven. The second one gets noticed. By the third, you’ve quietly become someone people stop fully trusting, even if nobody ever says it to your face.
I’ve had a version of this conversation with more than one musician over the years, most recently this week.
The Pattern I Keep Seeing
A musician subs a Broadway show. He also books and commits to his own gigs on the side, work he cares about outside the theater. Every so often, the calls to sub start landing on nights he’s already committed elsewhere. The Broadway gig often pays more. That’s just the truth. And every time it happens, he’s stuck with the same question: do I cancel the gig I already gave my word on for the one that pays better?
The musicians who’ve asked me this all say the same thing. It’s not that the money isn’t good. It’s that it doesn’t feel right to keep bailing on the gig they committed to first. But here’s what’s actually happening underneath that discomfort, whether they realize it or not: they’re tracking a number without meaning to. And so is everyone else.
On paper, canceling looks simple. More money, take the call. Almost anybody would. But the math never stays this clean, because it’s not a one-time trade. It’s a running tally.
Why the Third Time Is the One That Sticks
The first time you cancel a gig for a better one, most bandleaders let it go. It happens. Life happens. They might even respect that you took the bigger shot. The second time, something shifts. Not out loud, but they start wondering if it’ll happen again. By the third time, the wondering is over. They already know the answer, and they start planning around it. Quietly, without a conversation, you go from the first call to the backup.
I understand this from both sides, because I’ve lived both of them. I’ve been the one who felt the pull to take the higher-paying gig instead of the one I already committed to. And I’ve been the one calling subs for my own gigs. If I call someone and they can’t make it, that’s not a problem — I just move to the next name on my list. But if they say yes, commit to the gig, and then bail on me later, that’s different. That’s the one that actually costs them.
When it happens once, I notice. When it happens more than once with the same person, I stop calling them first, because I’ve learned I can’t count on their yes.
That’s the part nobody tells you. It’s never one dramatic conversation where someone says “I don’t trust you anymore.” It’s just fewer calls. A gig that used to be yours is going to someone else, with no explanation, because none was needed.
So the honest advice isn’t “never cancel.” It’s this: treat every cancellation like it’s using up a limited number, because it is, whether or not anyone’s counting out loud. Save it for the moments that are genuinely rare. A real tour offer. A once-in-a-lifetime call. Not “a little more money this week.” And when you do have to use one, do it right: give real notice, find your own sub, and own the conversation instead of disappearing into a text message.
I’ll be honest: canceling a gig never feels good, even when it’s the right call. I generally don’t like doing it, and I don’t think you should get comfortable with it either. It’s uncomfortable for a reason. That discomfort is worth listening to, because it’s telling you something true: this costs you, even when it doesn’t feel like it in the moment. Do it rarely enough and people understand. Do it too often, and it quietly catches up with you.
You can build a great career saying yes to the bigger gig sometimes. But you build a career on being the person people trust to show up. The count is always running, whether you’re keeping track of it or not.
If this is the kind of thing you want in your inbox, hit subscribe. I write about this stuff every week.
Where’s your number? How many cancellations is one too many for you? Tell me in the comments.